In the past I've been going with the Cool Water for Men type scents. Clean, fresh, masculine and predictable. One of the things I'd like to do is try things that it would normally not occur to me to wear. Florals, tobacco type scents... since women seem to know what smells good better than men do, I've been reading the women's reviews of the men's products.
I have recently gotten Michael Storer's Winter Star and Monk. Monk's my favourite of the two, it has a very mysterious sort of vibe to it... somehow it has the smell of burning incense in it, that smokey smell. I'd like to try some that have an aura of mystery and power to them. The Arthurian-Legend-type scents intrigue me, Pendragon, Merlin, Excalibur etc. Also Evil In Carnation.